Who is your top 10 Indians of all time?

[prepballfan]

This does not mean the 10 most statistically dynamic. Who are the Indians who, in your mind, are some of the most impactful you have watched play?
Ron McGill
Dustin Long
Bryan Bost
Roschon Johnson
Preston Riggs
Logan LeJune
Chris Gholke
Adam Morse
Jeremy Davis
Joey Price WR & K
This is off the top of my head.... May change this later

 

[IndianFan]

Sorry but I can't limit my list to 10! But I will mention my 10+ favorite offensive skill position players of all time that I've seen play, in chronological order + a few more.

Offensive Skill Positions
Jeff Bergeron
Richy Ethridge
Justin Eicher
Ron McGill
Dustin Long
Josh Cook
Adam Morse
Kaleb Sparks
Roschon Johnson
Preston Riggs
+
Mark Buchanan
Kyle Aguillard
Jackie Havard
Ronnie Delcambre
James Shipley
Caleb Harmon

I've got another 10+ favorites from the offensive line and 10+ on the defensive side too.

 

[pngfanatic]

Wow this is a tough one. I limited my list to just those players I actually saw play (1961 and after) and I still came up with 30+. Here are the 10 players from that elite list that sort of jumped off the page for me - from an impact perspective:

Jeff Bergeron
Roschon Johnson
Ron McGill
Richy Ethridge
Dustin Long
Chris Gohlke
Ted Brack
Preston Riggs
Logan Lejeune
Charlie Wallace
Honorable Mention - Ted Ancelot

Players like Gordon Leboeuf certainly belong on this list, but I unfortunately never saw him play.

 

[1989NDN]

Roschon Johnson
Jeff Bergeron
Richy Ethridge
Dustin Long
Justin Eicher
Ted Brack
Matt Burnett
Robert Giblin
Mike Simpson
Wilson Weber

I could name another 10 and there is not much drop-off in talent or greatness.

If we are including greatness off the football field, then I want to revise my list because I will have to find spots for Barbara Comeaux (there is not enough space on this web site for me to list all of her accomplishments), Tip Durham (the voice of PN-G), and Frank Gioviale (the creator of PN-G's version of Cherokee and the Marching I). I would also add the Ford family. Of all PN-G's great baseball players, has any of them out performed Lew Ford? He may play some type of professional baseball until he collects Social Security.

 

[IndianFan]

Roschon Johnson
Jeff Bergeron
Richy Ethridge
Dustin Long
Justin Eicher
Ted Brack
Matt Burnett
Robert Giblin
Mike Simpson
Wilson Weber

I could name another 10 and there is not much drop-off in talent or greatness.

If we are including greatness off the football field, then I want to revise my list because I will have to find spots for Barbara Comeaux (there is not enough space on this web site for me to list all of her accomplishments), Tip Durham (the voice of PN-G), and Frank Gioviale (the creator of PN-G's version of Cherokee and the Marching I). I would also add the Ford family. Of all PN-G's great baseball players, has any of them out performed Lew Ford? He may play some type of professional baseball until he collects Social Security.

More greatness off the field.
Coach Jerry Hooper (RIP)
Coach Butch Troy
Coach Granger (RIP)
Coach Lotice Cole
Coach Terry Cobb
Coach Mike Bradshaw

 

[IndianFan]

Defensive Favorites (too many to list)

These players had motors and were beasts! That’s what it takes to stand out on defense. Senior season listed.

Wilson Weber 1975
Ted Brack 1977
Robert DeRutte 1977
Gerrit Achord 1978
Jake Burnett 1992
Shawn Lang 1999
Chris Gholke 1999
Zeke Schexnider 2006
D.J. Shexnider 2010
Michael Hughes 2013
Trey Rembert 2015
Logan LeJeune 2018