My choice for most exciting game comes from way back - when I was 11 years old. It wasn't a playoff game, but it clinched the first 4A championship for PNG. We played the Orange Tigers in the last game of the season. The Tigers had a half game lead going into the game (we had tied South Park 0-0). The game was won as time expired by a 5 yard halfback pass from Charlie Wallace to R.H. Wallace (no relation). The description of that play by Charlie in Down Trails of Victory is priceless. Apparently R.H. had hands of stone, but all the other receivers were covered. Charlie finally reluctantly threw the pass to R.H. as he was going down while being tackled by the Tigers. I had no idea all of this was going on at the time. All I knew was that R.H. caught the pass and we won 14-12. I still get excited when I think about that play - 60 years later. Charlie Wallace was my PNG hero from that point on. Side note - my Dad worked at Dupont in Orange and invited a couple from Orange to go to the game with us. They were supposed to come over to our house after the game, but were so upset that they left immediately after the game. At least that's how my Dad always told the story of that game.