I was home from college for the summer of 1969. A couple of my buddies and I decided to check out the screen door. It was an interesting scene when we got there. It was crowded and everyone was trying to find a good position to see (and photograph) the image of Jesus. Some even climbed up in the trees in the backyard. The ground was littered with waste from Polaroid Instamatic film (the equivalent of cell phone cameras in those days). I remember one person saying he came all the way from Silsbee.
As I recall it, the Time article was a bit of a hit piece, focusing on some of the more outrageous comments. I also remember that local people were offended by the town being described as a "bleak, Gulf coast industrial town". I'm paraphrasing, but something like that.
Being irreverent college guys, we decided to make a joke. One of us (might have been me) said something about posing as screen door repairmen and taking the door in to repair the bulges in the screen. Needless to say that did NOT go over well with the people nearby who overheard us. Shortly thereafter, we decided it was a good time to leave.
For what it's worth, I only saw a lumpy screen.