Not even CLOSE!Reason for dictated broadcasting options.
Revenue generation: Broadcast licensing is an identified source of UIL income. Section 867 of the UIL Constitution and Contest Rules specifically identifies proceeds from radio and television broadcasting contracts as a revenue source.
Under Section 868 of the UIL Constitution and Contest Rules:
- UIL retains broadcast rights to all postseason events.
- UIL can enter into contracts with third parties to distribute those rights.
- Those contracts can cover television, Internet streaming, live broadcasts, delayed broadcasts, and other media.
- Even when a particular game isn’t covered by a third-party contract, UIL retains the rights.
The UIL’s Postseason Broadcast Information states the following:
ALL BROADCASTS MUST MEET THE FOLLOWING CRITERIA:
- The video broadcast must be provided to the public through a linear or reliable web broadcast with minimal buffering.
Postseason Video Broadcast Information Media Information — University Interscholastic League (UIL)
Postseason Video Broadcast Information Media Informationwww.uiltexas.org
Has NFHS met those requirements?
Clearly not.Reason for dictated broadcasting options.
Revenue generation: Broadcast licensing is an identified source of UIL income. Section 867 of the UIL Constitution and Contest Rules specifically identifies proceeds from radio and television broadcasting contracts as a revenue source.
Under Section 868 of the UIL Constitution and Contest Rules:
- UIL retains broadcast rights to all postseason events.
- UIL can enter into contracts with third parties to distribute those rights.
- Those contracts can cover television, Internet streaming, live broadcasts, delayed broadcasts, and other media.
- Even when a particular game isn’t covered by a third-party contract, UIL retains the rights.
The UIL’s Postseason Broadcast Information states the following:
ALL BROADCASTS MUST MEET THE FOLLOWING CRITERIA:
- The video broadcast must be provided to the public through a linear or reliable web broadcast with minimal buffering.
Postseason Video Broadcast Information Media Information — University Interscholastic League (UIL)
Postseason Video Broadcast Information Media Informationwww.uiltexas.org
Has NFHS met those requirements?
NFHS announcer can’t pronounce player names. Refers to team as Port Neches. Some have a problem keeping up with the down and distance. At times the viewing screen looks fogged up.YouTube: delivers the product it promises, doesn’t require making an account on a new platform, and is free.
NFHS: doesn’t deliver the product it promises, you have to deal with a whole new platform, is one of the most expensive streaming subscriptions out there (and it STILL has ads).
NFHS is the worst product on the internet. Even when it works it’s not good. An unpleasant experience in every context. It’s like paying ants to bite your foot.
PNG fans tune into the NFHS Liberty Hill pregame show. Take down/crash their telecast game site. UIL executive that keeps assigning PNG and Brenham to Region 2 to protect LH playoff hopes can experience what our huge PNG fan base has to deal with. Get off my front lawn.Then this might be considered a broadcast service compliance issue.
Some questions for the UIL might be:
When an NFHS postseason broadcast experiences persistent buffering, interruptions, freezing, or other technical deficiencies that materially impair the viewing experience, how does UIL determine whether this requirement has been satisfied?
If NFHS exercises its exclusive broadcast rights but fails to provide the reliable broadcast required by UIL’s own published standards, what obligation does UIL have to ensure that the viewing public receives the service it requires?
What corrective action is available when an NFHS broadcast fails to provide reliable coverage?
If the school has an already-approved, qualified broadcast production team, can that team be authorized to provide the broadcast when NFHS cannot deliver a reliable viewing experience?
The UIL has legitimate responsibilities concerning broadcast rights, commercial arrangements, and consistent administration. But those responsibilities should not become disconnected from the educational and community purposes for which the organization exists.
There are too many fans that depend on these broadcasts. The UIL must allow alternatives that meet their obligations to the fans and communities.
5A DII AREA ROUND
PN-G Indians (8-3)
vs.
Marshall Buffalos (8-3)
Friday, November 20, 7:00PM