Our defense is better than montgomery’s. They’re defense isn’t even as good as last year, despite their undefeated record. They’ve played five teams who made the playoffs this year, and allowed the following points: lake creek (35), west fork (2, but that was a safety so I don’t count it), Huntsville (35), Dayton(55), and Pflugerville (28). That’s 30.6 points a game given up by montgomery’s starters. If we assume pflugerville’s last td was against backups (it was in 3rd quarter with game pretty much out of hand, if MaxPreps is to be believed), that brings their average to 29.2 points a game given up by their starters when playing a playoff quality team (I’m using “playoff” as stand-in for “good,” since it gives us an objective comparison).
PNG has played eight playoff teams: PAM (35), Crawford (28), Brenham (45), Texas city (6, with the score going up to 23 with backups in), Dayton (0), Nederland (21), west fork (7, with the score going to 21 with backups in), and FBM (13).
If you include total scores (including ones allowed by backups), png gave up 23.25 points per game against playoff teams.
If you adjust out the scores given up by backups, png gave up 19.37 points a game against playoff teams.
If you don’t include the preseason for png (which would be fair, given that Montgomery didn’t play a single playoff team in the preseason so it measures the same stretch of games), PNG’s starters have given up 9.4 points per game against playoff teams. I actually like the measurement quite a bit because it captures how the two teams have been playing lately. We’ve been playing better lately. For example, in the playoffs Montgomery has given up 55 and 28. We gave up 21 and 13.
However you slice it, PNG’s defense is better, and much more experienced. They’re about 10 to 12 points worse than us per game (including being 55 points worse than us against Dayton). They’re 20 points worse than us per game if you don’t include the preseason. They’re about 28 points per game worse in the playoffs. In other words, I think we have a big advantage on defense.